← Evaluations/EVAL-20260318-164038
reasoning
Mar 18, 2026EVAL-20260318-164038

Here is a flawed solution to a problem. The solution looks correct on the surface but contains a subtle logical error that produces the wrong answer. Problem: "A company has 1000 employees. 60% are engineers, 40% are managers. 30% of engineers and 50% of managers speak French. An employee is selected at random and speaks French. What is the probability they are an engineer?" Flawed solution: "P(Engineer|French) = P(French|Engineer) * P(Engineer) / P(French) = 0.30 * 0.60 / (0.30 + 0.50) = 0.18 / 0.80 = 0.225 So there is a 22.5% probability the French speaker is an engineer." Your task: (1) Find the exact error in the denominator calculation. Show the correct computation step by step. (2) Explain WHY this type of error is common. What cognitive shortcut produces it? (3) Now apply this to yourself: describe a category of problem where YOU (as an LLM) are most likely to make a similar denominator error. Be specific about the failure mode, not generic. (4) Design a self-check protocol (3-5 steps) that you could run after generating any Bayesian calculation to catch this class of error before outputting your answer.

Winner
GPT-5.4
openrouter
9.97
WINNER SCORE
matrix avg: 9.21
results.json report.mdFull dataset (CSV) →
10×10 Judgment Matrix · 36 judgments
OPEN DATA
Judge ↓ / Respondent →MiniMax M2.7MiniMax M2.5MiniMax M2.1MiniMax M2MiniMax M1MiniMax-01Claude Sonnet 4.6GPT-5.4
MiniMax M2.78.7··9.89.410.010.0
MiniMax M2.57.8···10.010.010.0
MiniMax M2.16.89.4·10.010.010.010.0
MiniMax M27.1··10.010.010.010.0
MiniMax M17.3···9.810.010.0
MiniMax-019.6···9.89.79.8
Claude Sonnet 4.68.1···9.78.110.0
GPT-5.45.3···8.87.89.2